Connect with us

Editorial

Why The Gang-Up Against SERAP?

Published

on

Daily Courier Editorial – May 15th, 2026

The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project, SERAP, is once again at the center of a storm. On May 5, 2026, the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja, awarded ₦100 million in damages against SERAP in a defamation suit brought by two officials of the Department of State Services, DSS. The court also ordered public apologies, ₦1 million in litigation costs, and 10% annual post-judgment interest. d8b8

SERAP has called the judgment “a travesty and a miscarriage of justice” and filed an appeal on May 8, 2026, alongside an application for a stay of execution. The organization argues that the trial court relied on defective evidence, including a witness statement not sworn before a Commissioner for Oaths, and that the decision rests on fundamental legal and evidential errors.

That is the genesis of the “₦100 million legal hammer.” What followed is more troubling: a public pile-on where some civil society groups and student bodies have turned against SERAP, amplifying the DSS narrative before the appeal is heard. When the very ecosystem meant to defend civic space begins to fracture from within, the danger is not just to SERAP. It is to the principle of accountability itself.

MORE STORIES:https://dailycourier.com.ng/nigerian-american-dr-osato-osemwengie-hailed-as-u-s-drone-builder-for-pioneering-work-in-robotics/

The Danger of Muzzling CSOs

SERAP’s work has always been uncomfortable for power. From suing the CBN over alleged missing ₦3 trillion, to challenging governors and the FCT Minister over unaccounted security votes, to taking the Tinubu government to the ECOWAS Court over mass phone-tapping regulations, the organization has made a career of asking questions others avoid. That is its mandate under Section 22 of the 1999 Constitution, which imposes a democratic obligation on the media and civic actors to hold government accountable.

A ₦100 million judgment, if allowed to stand as a precedent, risks weaponizing defamation law into a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation, or SLAPP. A recent study presented by researchers noted that the Cybercrimes Act 2015 and criminal defamation are increasingly used to suppress free expression and shrink civic space. Human rights lawyer Inibehe Effiong has warned that state institutions are enabling harassment through abuse of police powers and judicial loopholes. When CSOs and student bodies join that chorus, they become accomplices in narrowing the space they themselves depend on.

Let the Legal Process Run Its Course

Nigeria’s legal history is full of cases where trial courts got it wrong, only for appellate courts to correct the course. The late Chief Gani Fawehinmi lost several cases at the lower courts but won landmark victories at the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court that expanded civil liberties and public interest litigation. That is why Section 36(1) of the Constitution guarantees fair hearing, which includes transparency, access to judicial decisions, and a meaningful opportunity to exercise appellate rights.

SERAP has already filed its appeal and applied for a stay of execution. More than 50 civil society groups have backed SERAP and demanded the immediate release of the Certified True Copy of the judgment, citing concerns over procedural fairness and due process. The proper response is to let the Court of Appeal examine the record, not to conduct a public conviction campaign based on a ruling that SERAP says is unsupported by evidence.

Accountability Must Be Held to Its Own Standard

This is not a defense of carelessness. Justice Yusuf Halilu, in his judgment, emphasized that “care and due diligence” must be taken before publishing allegations against government agencies. That standard applies to SERAP as much as it applies to the state. Civil society loses moral authority if it trades in untested claims or fails to distinguish between suspicion and proof.

But the answer to alleged overreach by a CSO is not to cheer when a ₦100 million judgment is used to silence it. The answer is to insist on facts, due process, and the right to appeal. The Northern coalition’s recent statement on the USPF allegations put it well: “Responsible civic engagement demands balance, verification and fairness”. SERAP, as an organization that demands that standard from government, must live by it too.

The Path Forward

Civil society in Nigeria has never been monolithic, and disagreement is healthy. But there is a difference between critique and a gang-up that seeks to delegitimize one of its own before the courts have spoken. If SERAP’s appeal succeeds, the current outcry will look like premature triumphalism. If it fails, the judgment will still need to be tested against constitutional standards of free expression and fair hearing.

Click on the link below to follow DAILY COURIER on WhatsApp : https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaAJv3FFnSz23aQ4Ab1M

For Daily Courier, the principle is simple: allow the entire legal process to take its course. Resist the temptation to muzzle dissent through intimidation or financial ruin. And urge all CSO actors, including SERAP, to pursue their causes with truth and justice as pillars, not rhetoric and assumption.

Democracy does not die in a single judgment. It erodes when those who claim to defend it turn on each other.