Connect with us

National News

Federal High Court Nullifies N40bn Vehicle Purchase, N70bn NASS Allowances

Published

on

Emmanuel Kelechi, Lagos

DAILY COURIER — The Federal High Court in Lagos has declared the National Assembly’s controversial N110 billion vehicle and allowance scheme unlawful, ruling that the plan to spend N40 billion on 465 SUVs for lawmakers and N70 billion in “support allowances” for new members breached procurement laws, constitutional duties and public trust.

Justice Yellim Bogoro delivered the judgment on Wednesday, May 6, 2026, in Suit No. FHC/L/CS/1606/2023 filed by the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project against Senate President Godswill Akpabio and Speaker Tajudeen Abbas. A certified true copy of the judgment was sighted on Sunday.

The court specifically nullified the allocation of N40 billion for 465 bulletproof vehicles at about N305 million per vehicle, and N70 billion in support allowances for newly elected lawmakers under the Supplementary Appropriation Act 2022 signed in 2023.

Justice Bogoro held that “looking at the magnitude of the expenditure, coupled with the absence of demonstrable due process, leads me to conclude that the procurement is arbitrary, disproportionate and inconsistent with statutory procurement standards.”

The judge said the fact that “the beneficiaries of the expenditure are the very officials approving it, and the expenditure confers direct pecuniary and material benefits” amounted to “self-dealing and conflict of interest.”

MORE STORIES: https://dailycourier.com.ng/mass-freedom-army-smashes-boko-haram-stronghold-rescues-360-hostages-in-borno-mountains/

Taking judicial notice of Nigeria’s economic realities, Justice Bogoro stated: “The allocation of N110 billion for the benefit of lawmakers demonstrates a failure to prioritise national interest” amid widespread financial hardship.

The court rejected the National Assembly’s argument that legislative autonomy barred judicial review. “The doctrine of separation of powers does not operate as a shield for illegality,” the judge ruled, stressing that courts can examine the legality of legislative spending.

SERAP argued the plan violated Section 57(4) of the Public Procurement Act 2007. The court agreed, noting the absence of competitive bidding and due process in a project of such scale.

Justice Bogoro also held the spending breached paragraph 1, Part 1, Fifth Schedule of the 1999 Constitution, which sets the Code of Conduct for public officers, and the Oath of Office under the Seventh Schedule.

“The allocation of N110 billion for the benefit of lawmakers also undermines the fiduciary duty owed to the Nigerian people. Public office must not be used for personal enrichment,” the court held.

The judge ordered the Senate President and Speaker “to ensure that all future procurements or expenditure of public funds by the National Assembly comply strictly with due process requirements and are also guided by the principles of transparency, accountability and value for money.”

SERAP filed the suit in August 2023 after reports emerged that the 10th National Assembly planned to acquire 465 bulletproof SUVs and pay N70 billion allowances to new lawmakers at a time inflation and fuel costs were biting Nigerians.

The defendants argued the court lacked jurisdiction, that SERAP lacked standing, that pre-action notice was not served, and that the funds had already been expended, making the suit academic. The court dismissed all objections.

On locus standi, Justice Bogoro ruled that “the law has now evolved to recognise public interest litigation. NGOs as SERAP in this suit can institute actions to protect public interest.”

The court held that while the Legislative Houses Act requires three months’ notice, the rule does not apply where matters are urgent or involve public interest. SERAP’s letters titled “Re: Request to Rescind the Scandalous National Assembly Budget of ₦110 Billion” were admitted as Exhibits A5 and A6.

Despite the defendants’ claim that money was already spent, the judge ruled that declaratory reliefs remain grantable and the case raised live constitutional issues on how public funds are used.

SERAP contended the allowances violated the remuneration framework set by the Revenue Mobilisation Allocation and Fiscal Commission. The court noted lawmakers cannot approve personal benefits outside RMAFC’s constitutional mandate.

SERAP Deputy Director Kolawole Oluwadare described the ruling as “a major victory for transparency, accountability and responsible management of public resources in Nigeria,” adding that “public office is a public trust.”

Human rights lawyer Femi Falana SAN said SERAP “deserves commendation,” stating that lawmakers’ lifestyle choices amid hardship “cannot be justified.” He urged RMAFC to enforce its mandate on legislative pay.

The planned N305 million per vehicle drew public outrage, with critics noting it far exceeded the price of similar armored vehicles in the open market and came as many Nigerians struggled with transport costs.

The N70 billion allowance for new members was framed as “constituency support” but critics argued it duplicated existing running costs and allowances already captured in the budget.

Click on the link below to follow DAILY COURIER on WhatsApp :https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaAJv3FFnSz23aQ4Ab1M

Legal analysts say the judgment will force the National Assembly to subject all future procurement to open bidding and legislative oversight, potentially reducing opaque “first line” allocations.

In her concluding remarks, Justice Bogoro said public officers “must act within constitutional boundaries and in good faith,” holding that the conduct complained of was “inconsistent with the oath of office.”

As of Sunday, the National Assembly had not issued an official response. Legal experts say the ruling could prompt a review of already-delivered vehicles and push RMAFC to publish a transparent breakdown of lawmakers’ entitlements.

The judgment adds to growing judicial scrutiny of public spending in Nigeria, with courts increasingly willing to intervene where executive or legislative actions conflict with procurement and constitutional standards.